Review – City of Thieves by David Benioff

city of thieves “We walked alongside the frozen Fontanka Canal, the ice littered with abandoned corpses, some covered with shrouds weighted down with stones, others stripped for their warm clothes, their white faces staring up at the darkening sky.  The wind was beginning to wake for the night and I watched a dead woman’s long blond hair blow across her face.  She had taken pride in that hair once, washed it twice a week, brushed it out for twenty minutes before going to bed.  Now it was trying to protect her, to shield her decay from the eyes of strangers.” (page 56)

City of Thieves by David Benioff is one of those books that I avoided for no good reason.  The subject matter seemed boring to me, another war novel, another novel about Russia that I just had no interest in reading.  Every once in a while, though, a book just keeps showing up in my life and I just have to pick it up.  This was the case with City of Thieves.  It was featured at B&N, I stumbled upon it in the stacks and finally it was there at the check-out lane at the library.  Then it moved to the top of my TBR pile by chance – it was the only book I had in my car one day.  So I started reading it and I’m so glad I did.

The one word that comes to mind after reading this book is absurd.  The book is about Lev and Kolya, two young Russian men who are doing their part to defend St. Petersburg/Leningrad/Piter from the Germans.  They both end up in prison one night, after Lev loots a dead German’s body and Kolya supposedly deserts the army.  Certain they are facing death, they strike up an unlikely friendship that continues to grow after they are sent on a ridiculous  mission by the commander: find a dozen eggs.  If they can find a dozen eggs for the commander’s daughter’s wedding cake, they will be set free.  Never mind that no one has seen an egg in Piter for six months.

So they go looking for eggs.  This book balances the tragedy and absurdity of war in an unlikely way.  It is humorous but it never forgets its setting; it is grand and it is base.  There are moments of laugh out loud debauchery and tear-inducing trauma.  I cannot tell you how well this book is researched, in terms of how accurate a representation it is of Leningrad during the German blockade, but it sure feels well-done.  It feels impeccably researched, but never loses the narrative in the history.  It combines a character-driven tale, a historical back-drop, mythic allusions and manages to be refreshing and original.  As for the ending, well, I might have seen it coming from a mile away, but it certainly felt satisfying and I might have cried just a little.

More quotes!

The boy sold what people called library candy, made from tearing the covers off of books, peeling off the binding glue, boiling it down, and reforming it into bars you could wrap in paper.  The stuff tasted like wax, butt here was protein in the glue, protein kept you alive, and the city’s books were disappearing like the pigeons. (52)

For a few seconds he helped me forget the fear, but it never left for long.  I could not remember when I was not afraid, but that night it came on stronger than ever before.  So many possibilities, but that night it came on stronger than ever before.  So many possibilities terrified me.  There was the possibility of shame, of cowering again on the fringe of the action while Kolya fought the Germans – except this time, I knew he would die.  There was the possibility of pain, suffering through the kind of torture Zoya suffered through, the saw teeth biting through my skin, muscles and bone.  There was the excellent possibility of death.  I never understood people who said their greatest fear was public speaking, or spiders, or any of the other minor terrors.  How could you fear anything more than death?  Everything else offered moments of escape: a paralyzed man could still read Dickens; a man in the grips of dementia might have flashes of the most absurd beauty.  (pg 136)

This book was just what I needed when I needed it, highly recommended.

So go read this:  now| tomorrow |next week | next month | next year | when you’ve exhausted your TBR pile

Also reviewed by: Trish’s Reading Nook & Bending Bookshelf

Did you read and review City of Thieves?  Tell me in the comments and I’ll link to your review!

13 thoughts on “Review – City of Thieves by David Benioff

  1. Like you, I have been avoiding this book as well! I am always intrigued by the cover, but then when I pick it up, it seems so dry and boring (for the reasons you outlined for avoiding it for so long). Maybe I will have to reconsider, given how much you enjoyed it.

    • Steph:

      Absolutely NOT dry and boring. Quite the opposite! There are lots of adjectives to assign this book, but not those two. I’m glad I’m not the only one who got that impression from the cover and dust jacket though! Maybe they need to do a better job marketing this one. I think you might like this one.

  2. It’s so cool when books just offer themselves to a person like that – I totally know what you mean about a certain volume appearing in your life over and over again until you finally agree to read it. And I’m glad that this one ended up being so rewarding for you; it sounds amazing.

    • Emily:

      I don’t usually ignore the book gods when they throw books into my face like that :), they usually know what they’re doing. I really enjoyed it and hope you will to if you read it!

  3. It’s already on my TBR shelf. I had the opposite reaction to it that you had. Another novel set in Russia during the war! Yippee! But, like you’ve, I’ve been a long time getting to it.

    Thanks for pushing it up to the front of the TBR line.

    Enjoyed your review.

    • CB:

      Hope you love it as much as I did! I always get wary when I recommend a book so highly and I’m afraid that people won’t like it as much as I did. Of course, I won’t be offended ;) I just hope you love it, that’s all!

  4. Pingback: Monthly Round-Up! November 2009 « Regular Rumination

  5. Pingback: Looking Back at 2009 « Regular Rumination

  6. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday – Top Ten Books that Made You Cry | Regular Rumination

Leave a Reply